• COVID-19 Park and Trail Closures
  • Learn about the Six-Pack of Peaks Challenge
  • Shop
  •  

SoCal Hiker

  • Find a Hiking Trail
    • All Areas
    • Arizona
    • Colorado
    • Los Angeles
    • Orange County
    • Oregon
    • San Francisco Bay
    • Washington
  • Trail Guides
  • Six-Pack of Peaks
    • Colorado Six-Pack of Peaks
      • Bergen Peak
      • Rocky Mountain
      • Birthday Peak
      • Horseshoe Mountain
      • Grays Peak
    • New England Six-Pack of Peaks
    • NorCal Six-Pack of Peaks
      • Mount Umunhum
      • Mount Saint Helena
      • Mount Tamalpais
      • Mount Diablo
      • Mount Sizer
      • Rose Peak
    • Oregon Six-Pack of Peaks
      • Tumalo Mountain
      • Black Butte
      • Black Crater
      • Maiden Peak
      • Mount Bachelor
      • South Sister
    • SoCal Six-Pack of Peaks
      • Mt. Wilson
      • Cucamonga Peak
      • Mt. San Antonio (Mt Baldy)
      • San Bernardino Peak
      • San Jacinto Peak
      • San Gorgonio
  • Backpacking
    • High Sierra Trail
    • John Muir Trail
      • Overview of the John Muir Trail
      • Training
      • Day-by-Day Itinerary
      • Resupply Addresses
      • JMT Discussion Forum
    • Lost Coast Trail
    • North/South Lake Loop
    • Rae Lakes Loop
    • Red Peak Pass Loop
    • Theodore Solomons Trail
    • Trans-Catalina Trail
    • Wonderland Trail
  • Gear
  • Forums
    • Latest Topics
    • Ask a Question
    • Campfire
    • Trails
    • Trail Reports
    • Gear Wisdom
    • Classifieds
  • Login

Keen Pyrenees Boots

March 1, 2010 By Jeff Hester 4 Comments

keen-pyrenees

For the past few years, I’ve been hiking and backpacking exclusively in New Balance trail runners — mostly dry day hikes and short 2-3 night backpacking trips. It’s worked well for me, but I have to admit that on some of the rough trails my feet feel pretty beat up at the end of the day. So for my John Muir Trail trip this year, I decided I wanted a little more protection.

After researching in several forums, reading online reviews and talking to other hikers, I was ready to head to my local REI and try some on.

REI is a great place to buy hiking boots or shoes. Not only do they have a dividend for members, but they offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

I tried on several pairs and ultimately chose the KEEN Pyrenees boots. They are an all-leather upper with a Nubuck finish and a waterproof liner. At 17 oz, they weigh the same as the nylon/leather KEEN Targhee II mid-height boots. I also replaced the foot bed with Superfeet insoles. The combination of the KEEN Pyrenees and the Superfeet insoles made these boots feel like butter.

The upside to an all-leather upper is improved protection and water resistance. The downside is that they generally require more breaking in time than an nylon or nylon and leather upper.

Breaking in the Boots: A Somewhat Unorthodox Approach

My boot guy at REI suggested I wear them around the house for an hour on Day One, then for four hours on Day Two. Really smart advice, but I took a slightly less conventional approach.

At one point, it felt like I was carrying a couple pounds of mud with me!

On Day One, I hiked 4-1/2 miles on the Colinas Bluff trail. It had rained during the night, so the normally dry dirt had turned to slippery mud. I was thankful I wasn’t wearing my trail runners! The boots kept my feet dry and gripped the slippery hills.

The next day, I hiked up Holy Jim canyon to Santiago Peak. At 5,687 feet, Santiago is the highest peak in Orange County. There were several small creek crossings, some patches of snow hiking, and it rained lightly during the course of this 16 mile hike. Of course, wearing new boots on a hike like this is a risky proposition, and I wouldn’t recommend it. I took a calculated risk based on my Day One experience with them, and was fortunate that it worked out well. I was prepared with moleskin and first aid if I had needed it, and in the worse case scenario, I could’ve turned back early toward the car. I was fortunate; the boots performed like champs, and fit like a glove. No hot spots or blisters at all.

My feet stayed warm and dry, even in the snow. Yes, that’s snow in Orange County!

Of course, hiking boots and footwear are a highly personal decision, but so far, I’m very pleased with mine.

Hiking Boot Shopping Advice

If you’re looking for some good advice on what to look for in a hiking boot, the Hiking Ladyhas some great advice. Though her advice was written “for women” the general advice applies to guys as well. I’ll just add that when you go to try on boots, bring along the socks that you’ll be using to hike in so you’ll get properly sized.

And even though your boots may claim to be waterproof, take the time to properly and lovingly waterproof them with Sno-Seal or similar treatment.

March 16th Addendum

This past weekend I hiked 19 miles on Blackstar Canyon, including some boulder scrambling around waterfalls. While scrambling on wet boulders, I noticed that the soles don’t have the same “grippiness” some shoes I’ve worn. They are described by Keen as “non-marking rubber.” I’m not sure what that means, but in my experience, “marking rubber” soles are a little more grippy. That being said, it wasn’t a problem and I’m still very happy with them. But I will exercise a skosh more caution on steep, slippery and hard services.

Related

Filed Under: Gear & Tips Tagged With: boots, Gear & Tips, KEEN, review

Like what you found here at SoCal Hiker? This site is a labor of love. Share your support for the site and help us development of new trail guides and expanded coverage -- make your next outdoor equipment purchase through our advertisers.

You can also subscribe to our weekly newsletter and follow us on Facebook or Twitter.

Jeff H

About Jeff Hester

I'm an avid hiker and backpacker. My wife Joan and I are on the trails every weekend. I started SoCal Hiker to share my passion for outdoor adventure.

Comments

  1. Hiking Lady says

    March 2, 2010 at 8:27 pm

    Great article! Thanks for the mention, and I’m glad you found my tips helpful. Santiago Peak sure is a daring place to test a new pair of boots. I’m glad to hear they worked well, even on all those switchbacks. Where are you taking the boots next? 😉

    Reply
    • SoCal Hiker says

      March 10, 2010 at 12:31 am

      @HikingLady: Next up? The Bridge to Nowhere in the San Gabriel mountains. I hear there are multiple creek crossings where the water is running thigh-high!

      @Derek: I still prefer trail runners for day hikes. I used my New Balance even when I did a 19.2 mile San Gorgonio ascent from Fish Creek, up that large-ish gravelly trail on the south side. I was blazing past everyone. Of course, my feet did feel every bump and were pretty tired at the end of the day, but the lighter weight made the trip easier overall. But I’m liking the idea of the greater protection afforded by boots, especially in snow, mud, water and carrying 30-35 lb backpack.

      Reply
  2. Derek (100 Peaks) says

    March 4, 2010 at 10:37 am

    Nice article. I wear the same green SuperFeet, too.

    I tested some new boots on the trail to Santiago Peak when I was young and invincible. 16 miles and two rattlesnake strike attempts later, I made it to the car with two blood-socked socks.

    Never again.

    I’ve switched to trail running shoes with light weight wool socks for hiking and have never looked back.

    It is nice to find a pair that just fits. Sometimes it takes years to find the right pair. For me, it is Vasque Blurs. I have three pair in my closet, ready to go when my pair wears out.

    Reply
  3. phoebe says

    August 21, 2010 at 10:40 pm

    Thanks for the tips. Your post is very informative. I am thinking for a major hiking in the high sierras. Now I can choose these brand hiking boots on my next adventure.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About Jeff Hester

I created SoCal Hiker while preparing to thru-hike the John Muir Trail. My goal? Create guides for the best hiking trails throughout Southern California--and occasionally beyond. I personally hike each trail to create these guides, sharing practical advice on gear and outdoor skills. Read more...

Connect with SoCal Hiker

  • 22,243 Fans
  • 11,791 Followers
  • 21,640 Followers
  • 1,689 Followers
  • 5,472 Subscribers
  • 333 Subscribers

Get the SoCal Hiker Newsletter

Sign up to get your weekly trail recommendation and the latest updates from SoCal Hiker.

SoCalHiker was selected one of USA TODAY's 10 Best Hiking and Outdoor Blogs
Get our day-by-day guide to thru-hiking the John Muir Trail
Get up-to-day wildfire status throughout California

Products

  • Mt Baden-Powell Replica Benchmark Mt Baden-Powell Benchmark $39.95
  • Mt Wilson Mug Mt Wilson Mug $15.95
  • Quality, weather resistant and dishwasher safe SoCalHiker stickers. SoCal Hiker Stickers (2-pack) $3.50
  • Mt San Jacinto Benchmark $39.95

Sponsors

Sponsor SoCalHiker and see your banner here

Featured Posts

Hiking Black Mountain in Rancho San Antonio County Park

At 2,812 feet, Black Mountain looms large, way up, and behind, the smaller hills to … [Read More...]

Hiking Camelback Mountain via the Echo Canyon Trail

Camelback Mountain is the most popular mountain to hike in the Phoenix area for good … [Read More...]

Hiking to High Point on Palomar Mountain in the Cleveland National Forest

Appropriately named High Point is the highest peak in the Palomar Ranger District of … [Read More...]

Lastest Comments

  • Susan Alcorn on Hiking Mount Sizer Loop in Henry Coe State Park
  • Oliver John on 10 Overnight Backpack Trips in Southern California
  • Gustavo on Social Distancing on Public Trails
  • katrien on Gear Review: BioLite Stove
  • Jacob on Vital Link Trail to Verdugo Peak
Get your SoCalHiker stickers now

Get your SoCalHiker stickers!

Latest Posts

  • Hiking Black Mountain in Rancho San Antonio County Park January 31, 2021
  • Hiking Camelback Mountain via the Echo Canyon Trail December 9, 2020
  • Hiking to High Point on Palomar Mountain in the Cleveland National Forest December 4, 2020
  • Hiking Hot Springs Mountain on the Los Coyotes Reservation November 19, 2020
  • New Day Hiking Permit Requirements for Wilderness Areas in the San Bernardino National Forest August 31, 2020

Recent Forum Topics

  • 1st overnight backing trip
  • Recommendations for trips for me and my dog
  • log hikes
  • My Baldy
  • Cactus to Clouds v. Iron Mountain

The Six-Pack of Peaks Challenge Series

Six-Pack of Peaks Challenge SeriesThe Six-Pack of Peaks Challenge gives you an opportunity to explore your world while supporting a great cause.

Flex your adventure muscles!

Learn more here.

 

Search

Tags

3-6 miles 6-8 miles 8-10 miles 11+ miles Arizona Backpacking coastal dog-friendly easy family-friendly High Sierra Trail hiking Hiking The John Muir Trail hipster inspiration JMT John Muir John Muir Trail Kings Canyon National Park LA County moderate Mount Rainier National Park Muir Monday National Forest National Park Orange County Oregon out of bounds Pacific Crest Trail peak peakbagging quote scenic Sierra Nevada Six-Pack of Peaks State Park strenuous Thru-hiking Utah vista Washington waterfall wilderness Wonderland Trail Yosemite

Copyright © 2021 SoCalHiker.net · Metro Theme on Genesis Framework with WPEngine Hosting · Contact SoCal Hiker · Sitemap · Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in